The steadily increasing Solar luminosity and the present continental configuration
conspire against it, but a large asteroidal or cometary impact could possibly
trigger a snowball earth given the present cold ocean.
This is a fair question given that the global climate has cooled dramatically
over the last 50 million years and 20 thousand years ago (the Last Glacial
Maximum) the ice extent was as great as at any time since the last snowball
earth. On the other hand, the Sun is nearly 6% more luminous now than during
the
Marinoan snowball earth, when lowering
greenhouse gases to present levels
triggers a snowball earth in most climate models. As Solar luminosity will
only rise in future, a snowball earth becomes a progressively less likely
outcome.
If a preponderance of tropical continents made the globe cold (see
What
caused the snowball earths?), the present geography with its enlarged
boreal and
subtropical land areas should have made it relatively warm. Before the ongoing
intervention by our own species, this this was not the case. A likely explanation
is that the rate of global CO
2 emission from volcanoes has declined.
Dan
Schrag
at Harvard University in Cambridge, USA suggests that this is because there
is little carbonate sediment on the floor of the Pacific Ocean and therefore
little CO
2 release from volcanoes of the Pacific "
ring
of fire".
He predicts that when subduction switches to the carbonate-rich Atlantic Ocean,
the globe will warm again. Schrag also thinks that the present large boreal
land
areas acts as a "safety switch" preventing extreme lowering of
CO
2. When it gets cold, these land areas are covered by ice sheets
and silicate
weathering is
diminished. When the snowball earths occurred there was little
high-latitude continental area. Large polar sea-ice caps developed that reflected
Solar radiation but did not cover much land area. According to this reasoning,
a snowball earth is unlikely without a major redistribution of the continents.
On the other hand, a climate model predicted that if the 10-km-diameter asteroid
that hit the Earth 65 million years ago extinguishing the dinosaurs and many
marine lineages hit instead today, a snowball earth would result. This is
because the present cold ocean is more susceptible to surface freezing than
the warm
Cretaceous ocean (when a snowball earth did not occur) during the
decade of reduced Solar forcing due to dust thrown up by the impact.